Summary: (From Amazon)
In this alternative history, a magical barrier protects most people from the dangerous magical creatures of the Wild West. Eff is a 13th unlucky child who supposedly will cause doom and misfortune, and is twin sister to Lan, the lucky and extra-magical 7th son of a 7th son. This novel covers a lot of ground both in time, following Eff from when she’s 5 until she’s 18, and in distance, as Eff’s family moves to the Western frontier when Eff’s magic-professor father and practical mother decide that the move will hide Eff and Lan’s differences. Then Lan’s potential is revealed after he causes an annoying classmate to float. When he leaves to go to school back East, Eff follows her own path to learning more about magic, including assisting in caring for the magical creatures at her father’s college. Her narration provides background about life in this version of early America, where magic helps with daily chores but brings its own dangers. Eff’s life in Lan’s shadow will ring true to all siblings of a particularly talented child, but at the conclusion it’s Eff who uses her own magic to rescue her twin. Reminiscent of Orson Scott Card’s “Alvin Maker” books (Tor), this is an interesting, but often slow-moving tale.—Beth L. Meister, Milwaukee Jewish Day School, WI
My Thoughts:
I spotted this on a train the other day in HC. Okay…so I spotted the dragon first. As soon as I could, I googled it up, and boy did I get more than I asked for. There was whole mess of controversy that I had apparently missed, but first thing first: let’s talk about the packaging. <3
I love covers like this where an imaginative treatment is given to text and that becomes the main component of the cover. It reminds me of an old newspaper or farmer’s almanac; however, this is not a trend I’d like to see widely used. Can you just imagine the tunnel vision if this sort of treatment were as prevalent in the bookstores as the current photo-realistic, single female standard? Oye.
It’s so simple, but it all works. The font is elegant, but sharp. The starkness of the tea stained background really sets off the text and the simple images of a farm and dragon. It’s obvious that it’s Victorian, maybe steampunk-esque but you can’t tell much else from the cover.
I’m looking forward to picking this up in paperback in April 2010 all controversy aside. You can hit up the Amazon comments and reviews for a briefing on all of it. The removal of all Native Americans from this alternate American landscape and a comment or two by Patricia C. Wrede during the writing process of this book was the heart of it during the whole RaceFail 09 saga.
From a consumer standpoint, I am disappointed that these societies were removed from the story because it’s something I would have liked to have read. From what I can tell of the premise, there is a lot of cross-cultural blending of magic systems and beliefs. I’d have liked to have maybe seen Native American spiritualism interact with some of these things, but ah well. I remain interested and excited for this book. It is was it is. The whole point of alternate and fantastical histories is to explore a moment in time with additions or subtractions contrary to the known timeline.
/End of Line
~ L.

So on a whim I wanted to do another cover round up, as I did for A Wild Sheep Chase by Haruki Murakami. And originally I set off to do Dune because being such an internationally well known piece of classic SF, I figured there would be a treasure trove of awesome vintage covers. It’s also one of my favorite books, period.




